Home Services Calculators Blog Contact About Credit Guide & Compliance Call (02) 8003 4306
Getting a loan

Comparison rate explained: what it shows and what it misses

Every home loan ad shows two rates. The second one is meant to make comparing easier, and mostly it does. Here’s how it’s worked out, and the situations where it points you the wrong way.

ShareFacebookLinkedInWhatsAppX

Quick answer: a comparison rate rolls a loan’s interest rate and most of its fees into one percentage. It’s worked out on a $150,000 loan over 25 years, so on bigger loans it can overstate what fees cost you. In our example below, a loan with a $395 annual fee has the higher comparison rate but costs about $1,100 less in the first year on a $750,000 loan.

What the comparison rate includes

Moneysmart describes it as a single figure that combines the interest rate with most of the fees and charges on the loan. In practice that means:

  • the interest rate, including any rate the loan reverts to after an introductory or fixed period
  • upfront lender fees, such as application or establishment fees
  • ongoing lender fees, such as a monthly service fee or an annual package fee

Why it uses $150,000 over 25 years

To make rates comparable, every lender works the comparison rate out on the same example: a secured loan of $150,000 over 25 years. That’s why every advertised comparison rate comes with a warning that it’s true only for that example, and that a different loan amount or term would give a different result.

The catch is that most home loans today are much bigger than $150,000, and many run for 30 years. A fixed dollar fee is a large share of a small loan and a small share of a big one, so the standard example tends to make fees look more expensive than they are for a typical Sydney borrower.

When the lower comparison rate costs more

Take two variable loans. Loan A is a package at 5.89% with a $395 annual fee. Loan B is a basic loan at 6.09% with no fees.

Illustrative example. First-year figures are interest plus fees on a 30-year principal and interest loan.
Loan A: 5.89% + $395 a yearLoan B: 6.09%, no fees
Comparison rateabout 6.24%6.09%
First-year cost on $150,000$9,180$9,085
First-year cost on $750,000$44,319$45,425
Monthly repayment on $750,000$4,444$4,540

On the standard $150,000 loan, Loan B is cheaper by about $95 a year, which is what the comparison rates suggest. On a $750,000 loan the 0.20% rate gap is worth far more than the fee, and Loan A comes out about $1,100 a year cheaper. In this example the two cost about the same at a loan size of roughly $197,500. Above that, the lower rate wins.

Introductory and fixed rates

This is where the comparison rate earns its place. Because it takes in the rate the loan reverts to, a big gap between the advertised rate and the comparison rate is a signal. A sharp introductory rate that jumps after a year or two, or a fixed rate that rolls onto a high variable rate, will show a comparison rate well above the headline number. Look at the revert rate before you choose. See fixed vs variable and what to do when a fixed rate ends.

What the comparison rate leaves out

  • Government charges. Stamp duty and registration fees aren’t part of it.
  • Lenders mortgage insurance. LMI depends on your deposit, so it isn’t in the advertised figure.
  • Fees that depend on what you do, such as break costs on a fixed loan or late payment fees.
  • Cashback offers. These generally sit outside the comparison rate, and they often come with conditions.
  • Features. An offset account you’ll use, or limits on extra repayments, can be worth more than a small rate difference, and neither shows up in the number.
  • The rate you could negotiate. Advertised rates are a starting point. Many borrowers end up on a lower rate than the one in the ad.

How to compare loans side by side

  1. Ask for a Key Facts Sheet for each loan. It shows a comparison rate worked out on your loan amount and term, the total you’d repay, and the fees. Moneysmart recommends comparing them side by side.
  2. Work out the first-year cost on your own loan size: interest plus all fees.
  3. Check the revert rate on any introductory or fixed loan.
  4. Price the features you’ll use, such as an offset account, and drop the ones you won’t.

This is the comparison we run when we look across our panel of 40+ lenders. Our loan comparison calculator lets you try two loans yourself. Source: Moneysmart, choosing a home loan.

Comparison rates: common questions

What is a comparison rate?

A single percentage that combines a home loan’s interest rate with most of its lender fees. For home loans it’s calculated on a $150,000 secured loan over 25 years, so lenders can be compared on the same example.

Why is the comparison rate higher than the interest rate?

Because it adds the loan’s fees, and any higher rate the loan reverts to after an introductory or fixed period. A large gap usually means high fees or a much higher revert rate.

Is the loan with the lowest comparison rate always the cheapest?

No. The standard example uses a $150,000 loan, so fees look relatively expensive. On a larger loan, a lower interest rate with an annual fee can cost less overall than a no-fee loan with a lower comparison rate.

Does the comparison rate include LMI or stamp duty?

No. Government charges, lenders mortgage insurance and fees that depend on events, such as break costs, sit outside it. Cashback offers generally aren’t included either.

General information only, not financial or credit advice. Rates in the example are illustrative and aren’t offers from any lender. Comparison rates are true only for the example given.

More on getting a loan

All getting a loan guides →

Comparing two loans already?

Send us the details and we’ll work out what each one costs on your loan size, then show you what else is available across 40+ lenders.

Book a free chat
All articles